Milwaukee's basements have been tested by two very different storms. On July 22, 2010, Mitchell Field recorded 5.61 inches of rain in a day, and Milwaukee County received a Major Disaster declaration. On August 9 into August 10, 2025, a gauge at James Madison High School in northwest Milwaukee read 14.55 inches, confirmed as a new Wisconsin 24-hour record, and flash flooding reached Wauwatosa, West Allis, Menomonee Falls and New Berlin. For you, that means the first job before hiring is working out where the water comes from. MMSD says that if neighbours have backups at the same time as you, the public sewer is likely full and pushing water in through your sanitary lateral. If they are not affected, your lateral is likely blocked. A sump pump or waterproofing will not fix a sewer backup, so ask any contractor to explain which problem they are treating, what permit the work needs, and what the written quote covers. Ask about MMSD's Pipe Check programme too.
Sources: National Weather Service Milwaukee/Sullivan (source, opens in a new tab), National Weather Service Milwaukee/Sullivan (source, opens in a new tab)